What Does Umberto Eco Tell Us About Fascism?
Umberto Eco was an extraordinary individual. As the author of numerous books and a leading researcher in the field of semiotics, he deeply explored various cultural and social phenomena. In 1995, he published the essay “Eternal Fascism,” where he outlined 14 defining characteristics of this ideology, providing us with a valuable tool for recognizing and analyzing it.
Although Eco’s essay is not a definitive interpretation of fascism, it remains an important and insightful source for enhancing our understanding of this dangerous ideology and its contemporary manifestations.
One of the most striking features of fascism that Eco describes is the cult of tradition. Within this framework, fascists reject Critical thinking and innovation. They tend to cling to outdated beliefs and practices, resisting any form of change or progress in all areas of life. For instance, in Italian fascism, Mussolini emphasized a return to the traditional values of Ancient Rome.
Furthermore, fascist ideology often relies on myths, fantasies, and propaganda glorifying strength and heroism. A vivid example is Nazi Germany, where propaganda heavily exploited mythical images of the Aryan race and the Übermensch. This trait is reinforced by a cult of national unity and a deep-seated hatred for “the others.” In such an environment, any difference is perceived as a threat to national unity.
Fascists also favor action over contemplation. They sanctify only “correct” beliefs and actively oppose individualism. By insisting on nationalism, fascists are antagonistic toward international cooperation, viewing it as a threat to national integrity. For example, Hitler considered the Treaty of Versailles humiliating and sought to restore Germany’s “true” power by unleashing aggression against neighboring states.
These characteristics represent just a portion of the wide range of traits described by Eco, and fascism can emerge in various forms. To prevent the mistakes of the past from repeating, it’s crucial for each of us to recognize fascism and understand its signs. This is especially important today, as different shades of neo-fascism can subtly infiltrate public consciousness disguised as patriotism or other seemingly innocuous identities.
In the next section of this article, we will delve into how to protect ourselves from fascist propaganda and explore self-development tools that can help us maintain vigilance and critical thinking.
Umberto Eco and His Polyphonic Work
Umberto Eco stands out as a brilliant figure in the landscape of contemporary Italian intellectual life. His multifaceted talent has shone through in various fields: Eco established himself not only as an outstanding scholar but also as a gifted writer, insightful literary critic, cultural theorist, and witty commentator. Worldwide acclaim and enduring fame came to him with his debut novel, The Name of the Rose, which quickly became a bestseller. Both literary critics and millions of readers around the globe regard this book as one of the greatest works of the 20th century.
However, it wasn’t just his literary achievements that made his name synonymous with brilliance; Umberto Eco was also an active public figure and tireless writer. His articles, essays, and monographs contribute significantly to modern thought while revealing unexpected dimensions of his intellectual prowess. Notable works include “Five Essays on Ethics,” “How to Write a Thesis,” and “Eternal Fascism.” These pieces not only analyze contemporary events and historical trends but also serve as guides through the intricate labyrinths of history and culture.
for free
Today, we will focus on one of his most timely and provocative studies: Eternal Fascism. In this monograph, Eco skillfully unpacks the essence and nature of fascism, offering a deep analysis of its roots and mechanisms, making the work relevant in today’s world. He illustrates how fascist ideologies can seep into society through seemingly innocuous slogans and rhetorical tricks. Notably, Eco outlines 14 characteristics of eternal fascism, serving as markers to identify similar movements in the political discourse of various countries and eras.
A prime example of his insightful analysis is the essay “How to Write a Thesis,” where the author not only discusses the technical aspects of academic work but also delves into the philosophical nature of the learning process, transforming a routine guide into an engaging read. Another testament to his courage and expansive thinking is found in his writings on ethics. Here, he astonishes readers with the breadth of his conclusions and his ability to guide them from complex theoretical reflections to practical implications.
Each work by Umberto Eco is a rich tapestry of ideas, offering a deep and layered analysis that leaves a lasting impression and encourages reflection. This is what sets him apart in the realm of intellectual thought.
“Eternal Fascism” – A Journalistic Masterpiece by Umberto Eco
Fascism stands as one of the most complex and multifaceted challenges humanity faced in the 20th century. In his monumental work, “Eternal Fascism,” Umberto Eco presents a theoretical analysis of the core principles of this ideology, carefully juxtaposing it with other forms of social organization, including Catholicism and Protestantism, communism, and democracy. Right from the early pages of this treatise, Eco skillfully illustrates how fascism manages to adapt to diverse cultural, economic, and political circumstances—elements that may initially seem incompatible.
The author argues that fascism is birthed from a multitude of factors, such as social instability, political crisis, cultural decline, moral decay, and ultimately, spiritual emptiness. In this work, Umberto Eco articulates the concept of “eternal fascism,” which he defines as a persistent negative potential, capable of emerging and thriving within specific areas of societal life. He draws attention to the remarkable flexibility of this ideology, allowing it to camouflage itself under various political and cultural conditions.
The polyphonic nature of Eco’s writings is particularly compelling. He transcends historical boundaries and specific examples to explore a wide array of historical eras and diverse fields of culture and science. Through his analyses, Eco establishes parallels between phenomena across different times and geographies—from antiquity to the modern era, from Europe to Asia. This approach invites readers to delve into an expansive ocean of contexts, encouraging them to compare and reconsider. For instance, Eco makes a surprising yet persuasive comparison between Roman Imperial cults and contemporary pop culture, demonstrating how mass manipulation and the cult of personality have remained unchanged through the ages.
Thanks to the polyphony and diversity of perspectives, Eco enables readers not only to understand the multifaceted nature of fascism but also to gain deep insight into the world we inhabit. His works spark intellectual curiosity and encourage a thorough analysis of contemporary social and political phenomena. A prime example is his detailed examination of Benito Mussolini’s regime, which he compares to other authoritarian governments that marked the 20th century. This approach makes Eco’s writings invaluable for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of complex social phenomena and looking for answers to today’s challenges.
Fascism in Light of Umberto Eco’s Essay “Eternal Fascism”
In 1995, renowned Italian writer and philosopher Umberto Eco published an essay titled “Eternal Fascism,” which became a profound exploration of the nature of fascism. In his work, Eco meticulously analyzes the characteristics of fascism and highlights the distinctions between the ideologies of Mussolini’s Italy and Nazi Germany. He emphasizes that Italian fascism was not a singularly unified ideology, whereas Hitler’s Nazism developed into a coherent and systematic doctrine of hate.
Eco also draws attention to a crucial point: unlike Nazi Germany, fascist Italy was not initially steeped in racism and anti-Semitism. However, Germany adopted extreme nationalism, anti-communism, and militarism from Italy, transforming these elements into a terrifying regime under the banners of terror and genocide. Thus, while Nazism can be confidently described as a unique phenomenon, Eco argues that fascism is more pervasive and should be examined within a broader context.
He presents readers with a list of 14 indicators of “eternal fascism” (or ur-fascism), each serving as a potential sign of a lean toward fascist ideology. These indicators include a cult of tradition, a rejection of critical thinking, and a fear of difference, among others. Eco asserts that if a state exhibits even one of these traits, it’s already a cause for concern. For instance, in a nation that reveres only traditional values while dismissing innovative ideas, a tendency toward fascist thought is already evident.
The more indicators that manifest in a state’s life, the more pronounced its fascist nature becomes. As these signs increase (from six to seven or more), the process becomes irreversible, akin to a growing snowball that is hard to halt. Therefore, Eco’s essay serves as a reminder that while fascism is a component of Nazism, it is not defined by it alone. Ignoring the signs of fascism could lead to a repetition of the tragic mistakes of the past.
Umberto Eco’s essay “Eternal Fascism” is a significant contribution to our understanding of the fascist threat and its various forms. This profound analysis emphasizes the need for vigilance against any signs of fascist rhetoric and behavior in today’s world, in order to prevent the recurrence of historical disasters reminiscent of those witnessed in the first half of the 20th century.
Signs of Fascism in Society
Fascism is heavily rooted in the culture of tradition and traditionalism, often presented as the unshakeable foundations of society. By adhering to this principle, fascists tend to cast doubt on modernism and the advancement of knowledge, viewing them as threats to traditional values. In countries with such views, you’ll notice an emphasis on reviving old customs and rejecting innovations that are seen as subversive to national identity. For instance, think of fascist Italy’s drive to revive the grandeur of the Roman Empire or how Nazi Germany emphasized living in harmony with “natural laws.”
Fascism encourages action over contemplation; decisions are frequently made based on intuition or impulse rather than through careful and deliberate reasoning. In this context, fascist movements often organize large-scale events where leaders call for immediate action rather than thoughtful reflection. Remember the infamous Nazi rallies in Nuremberg, where Hitler stirred the masses with his fiery rhetoric, inspiring instantaneous responses.
National identity is exalted to an absolute in fascist ideologies, with public focus directed toward combatting both external and internal enemies. Fascism demands unwavering loyalty to the nation and harbors contempt for “lower” societal groups, such as ethnic or religious minorities, who are viewed as threats to national unity. For example, anti-Semitism was a core tenet of Nazi ideology…
