Metamodernism: Exploring Its Impact on Art, Culture, and Modernity

Metamodernism: A New Evolutionary Phase in the Art World

Modernism and postmodernism are rightly regarded as key movements in 20th-century art. Modernism emerged at the beginning of the century as a bold call for a renewal of artistic standards. It celebrated the individual artist and their limitless creative freedom while opening the doors to a range of experimentation with forms, techniques, and materials. Notable achievements of modernism can be seen in the works of masters like Pablo Picasso and Kazimir Malevich. Picasso shattered conventional perceptions of reality with his cubist style, while Malevich declared victory for abstraction over figuration with his iconic “Black Square.”

In the latter half of the 20th century, postmodernism took the stage, pursuing synthesis and eclecticism by blending stylistic elements, cultural motifs, and historical layers. It served as a response to the exhaustion of modernist potential, offering ambiguous, ironic, and sometimes whimsical works. This era was marked by the creativity of figures like Andy Warhol, who refined the concept of pop art and skillfully manipulated mass culture and the symbols of his time.

Meanwhile, a new concept has emerged on the horizon of contemporary art, drawing ever-increasing attention—“metamodernism.” This movement has become a topic of discussion among art circles and cultural critics. Metamodernism offers a fresh and multifaceted perspective on art by considering and reinterpreting the experiences of previous stages. It doesn’t merely combine elements of modernism and postmodernism; it dives deeper into their meanings, creating a new synthesis of motifs and ideas.

For a deeper understanding of the concepts of modernism and postmodernism, it’s recommended to explore the relevant lessons in the course “History of Art”. However, this article will focus on metamodernism and its developmental context in the art world, revealing its unique characteristics and distinctions from other movements.

Let’s begin with a historical overview to better understand how metamodernism fits into the evolution of artistic concepts and the changes it has brought to the perception of art.

Ultimately, metamodernism isn’t just another phase or a return to the old ways. It’s an effort to conceptualize and reject the extremes of the past, offering a more flexible, emotional, and layered approach to creativity. A prime example of this is the work of Thomas Saraceno, who blends elements from both modernism and postmodernism. His poignant creations touch on profound human emotions and experiences, emphasizing the complex relationships between individuals and their environments.

Metamodernism: A New Wave of Cultural Reality

Since the early 1990s, significant and groundbreaking changes have emerged in the realms of art and culture, all grouped under the term “metamodernism.” This phenomenon isn’t merely a reflection of contemporary art; it’s a fresh perspective, a new cultural paradigm that transforms traditional boundaries into a dynamic and captivating continuum of the future. Metamodernism unveils new horizons and reinterprets familiar themes, enabling both viewers and artists to engage in a dance of irony and admiration.

This cultural paradigm can be described as an evolution from postmodernism to a new era of expressiveness and introspection. Key concepts within metamodernism include metaxis and parataxis. Metaxis involves a constant oscillation between opposing states—like hope and despair, naivety and irony. On the other hand, parataxis brings different elements together within a single text or artwork to create an unexpected harmonious whole, much like the techniques seen in poetry or the editing styles of film.

Take, for instance, the films of Wes Anderson, where unique visual styles and rich dialogues construct a distinct metamodern world, compelling the audience to both laugh and empathize. Another striking example is Zaha Hadid’s architecture, where the flowing, dynamic lines of her buildings reflect a pursuit of balance between chaos and order.

Metamodernism attracts not just the authors of “Notes on Metamodernism,” but also a multitude of researchers and individuals eager to deepen their understanding of contemporary shifts in culture and art. Ultimately, metamodernism reveals an unprecedented perspective on life, highlighting a unique relationship between instability and stability, and opening doors to a more profound, multilayered reality. It challenges the notion of permanence and instills a belief that art and the world can embody both seriousness and playfulness, complexity and simplicity, stability and changeability.

Metamodernism in Art

The contemporary world, with its intricate interactive processes and endless streams of information, demands not only our reactions but also a deep understanding of potential consequences. Art, as ever, reflects this world, aiming to penetrate the horizons of the past, present, and future to either enhance its beauty or highlight its imperfections. In this context, metamodernism emerges as a fresh movement in art, skillfully weaving together the achievements of postmodernism and modernism, while emphasizing their traditions and crafting a unique experience for the viewer.

Metamodernism embodies a distinctive and shifting state that exists between two diametrically opposed concepts: irony and sincerity, naivety and knowledge, relativism and truth, optimism and doubt. One of the key manifestos of this movement encompasses themes of liberation from the naivety of modernism, progression, acceptance of natural limitations and the incompleteness of systems, as well as a pursuit for scientific elegance and creative exploration of knowledge.

Delving deeper into metamodernism, we can say it represents a generalization, an abstraction, and a transition to a new perception of reality. As Luke Turner noted, “Metamodernism is an attempt to save the idea of progress and to present something greater than postmodernism. It’s not populism; it’s an effort to create genuinely complex art.” For instance, in the realm of cinema, the works of directors like Wes Anderson and Greta Gerwig exemplify these qualities, blending sincerity with irony and crafting intricate, multilayered narratives.

The art of metamodernism demands a clear direction and bold artistic expression. It manifests in works that seek innovation and stand apart from the traditional traits of modernism and postmodernism. For instance, artists like Banksy skillfully incorporate elements of metamodernism, blending protest culture with profound social and political issues. In this regard, metamodernism evolves into not just a means of self-expression but also an endeavor that marries scientific inquiry with creative aspirations, striving for both intellectual elegance and artistic originality.

Artistic Strategies of Metamodernism: A Purpose for Creating Artworks

Every era, whether it’s the baroque period with its elaborate decor and drama or the romanticism focused on emotion and natural beauty, has brought unique styles and techniques to the creation of art. In today’s world, we encounter an astonishing variety of artistic styles and methods that artists utilize to convey feelings, ideas, and conceptual meanings.

Recently, however, a distinctive approach has emerged in the art scene, known as metamodernism. This style plays with the boundaries of modernism and postmodernism, blending the finest elements of both movements to craft a completely unique and harmonious artistic language. Metamodernist strategies comprise a set of advanced techniques and practices that enable artists to express complex and layered ideas.

One key example of these strategies is the use of multiple perspectives. Unlike traditional approaches that narrate a story from a single, fixed viewpoint, metamodernism offers a nuanced, multifaceted perspective that allows viewers to experience the subject from various angles. Think of Pablo Picasso’s famous painting “Guernica,” which appears to be torn apart and reassembled, showcasing the horrors of war from different viewpoints.

Another example is the application of unconventional formats and methods. Metamodernist artists frequently challenge the norms by using unusual materials and techniques. This can range from outdoor installations to virtual reality experiences. A prime illustration is Olafur Eliasson’s work, where he often creates captivating installations like the “Weather Project.” In this project, artificial mist and a massive glowing disc evoke the sensation of a real natural phenomenon reimagined within an indoor space.

The use of metamodern artistic strategies enables artists to create works that blend elements from past eras with the present, weaving together threads of modernism and postmodernism. This fusion aids in achieving harmony amid artistic chaos, presenting viewers with fresh and nuanced ways to engage with art.

Performatism and the Surge of Interest in Theology in Art

Performatism is an intriguing and provocative concept introduced by cultural theorist Raoul Eshelman. This term describes the phenomenon of deliberate self-deception, allowing individuals to believe in something despite their own doubts and inner contradictions. According to Eshelman, performatism is the key to understanding the resurgence of interest in theology within contemporary art.

One of the most striking examples of this revival is the “Younger Than Jesus” exhibition at the New Museum in New York. This exhibition garnered significant attention not only for its unusual title but also for showcasing the work of young artists exploring spiritual and religious symbols through a modern lens. The installation highlighting the contrast between ancient theological ideas and new art forms captivated critics and the general public alike.

Interest in religious themes extends beyond the visual arts and reaches into pop music, where it manifests in diverse and often unexpected ways. For instance, the popular song “I_$USS” by the band Leningrad (pronounced like “Jesus”) vividly exemplifies this trend. The chorus, featuring the line “You, like Jesus,” is accompanied by a music video depicting a character styled as Jesus Christ. This provocative imagery, blending religious symbolism with contemporary musical context, underscores the ongoing dialogue between spiritual themes and popular culture.

Experimenting with religious symbols in contemporary art is becoming a trend that permeates various creative fields. Take, for instance, how Lana Wachowski, the director of the cult film “The Matrix,” employed biblical imagery and allusions to infuse her cinematic project with profound philosophical depth. Another example is the popular artist Kanye West, whose album “Jesus Is King” delves into themes of faith, spirituality, and religious liberation through experimental music and bold lyrics. Works like these blend spiritual essence with the dynamics of modern life, demonstrating that theology in art is alive and evolving, continuing to inspire thousands of people around the globe.

Metamodernism: Romance and Modernity

Metamodernism is an exciting and multifaceted artistic movement that emerged in response to the postmodern era. This movement skillfully integrates elements from past artistic styles, crafting a new kind of avant-garde that is rapidly gaining traction. However, its true beauty and complexity lie in the dualities and eternal fluctuations between opposing ideas, such as naivety and irony, sincerity and cynicism, utopia and dystopia.

To dive deeper into the essence of metamodernism, it’s essential to examine two of its key components: Romanticism and Modernity.

Romanticism within Metamodernism

Romanticism, an artistic and cultural movement that emerged in the late 18th to early 19th century, has always aimed for lofty ideas and emotional expression. In the context of metamodernism, these characteristics manifest through profound sincerity and a quest for genuine emotions. For instance, contemporary artworks often depict scenes brimming with vibrant feelings and heightened sensibility, reminiscent of the grandeur of the Romantic era. The creative endeavors of artists like Yoko Ono and David Lynch serve as striking examples of this influence.

Modernity within Metamodernism

On the other hand, Modernity represents a drive for innovation, technological advancement, and a break from traditional pasts. Within the framework of metamodernism, this aspect emerges through the use of cutting-edge technologies and experimental formats. Digital art and virtual reality often serve as platforms for creating metamodernist works. Projects like Rafael Loza’s interactive installations and Peter Hellermann’s digital canvases illustrate how artists merge technological advancements with avant-garde themes.

In summary, metamodernism effectively blends the Romantic yearning for the sublime with the Modernist thirst for innovation, giving rise to new forms of art and culture that will continue to inspire and captivate minds and hearts around the globe.

Romanticism and Metamodernism

In today’s artistic landscape, the metamodernist trend known as “Romantic Conceptualism” captivates with its ability to intertwine the grandeur and emotional richness of Romanticism with abstract conceptuality. This movement excels at harnessing emotional elements, breathing new life into them through the lens of contemporary artistic forms.

A striking example of Romantic Conceptualism is the work of French artist Didier Courbot. His paintings transport viewers into a realm of dreams and fantasies infused with the spirit of Romanticism, where every detail is laden with profound meaning and emotion. In one of his well-known pieces, “Summer Evening in Paris,” Courbot employs a playful palette of warm tones, evoking the light of a sunset washing over the city—an effect that instantly stirs feelings of nostalgia and enchantment.

Beyond painting, Didier Courbot actively engages in urban landscaping, further showcasing his commitment to the principles of metamodernism. The “Gardens for All” project in Marseille, led by Courbot, infuses the city’s boulevards with an extraordinary harmony of nature and art. Visitors can relish the sights of blooming gardens scattered throughout the city, which, thanks to the artist’s creative approach, transform everyday strolls into vibrant and memorable experiences.

Therefore, Romantic Conceptualism as interpreted through metamodernism exemplifies a remarkable blend of rationality and emotion, creating artworks that not only please the eye but also resonate deeply with the viewer’s soul.

Modernism and Metamodernism: The Evolution of Architectural Concepts

Architectural metamodernism can be seen as a captivating and multi-layered dialogue between the tenets of original modernism and the eclectic traditions of postmodernism. While modernism prioritized functionality and materials, and postmodernism injected irony and historical references, metamodernism takes it a step further, skillfully blending these elements into a new, imaginative reality.

One of the defining features of metamodernism is its rejection of strict minimalism. In this style, architects often experiment with unusual and fantastical forms, resulting in unique and memorable structures. Take, for instance, the Brandenburg University of Technology Library in Cottbus, which embodies minimalist principles while maintaining a fresh and functional design. However, metamodernism paves the way for creative experimentation, allowing architectural forms to be illogical and asymmetrical.

Consider the National Stadium in Beijing, famously known as the “Bird’s Nest.” This remarkable project, designed by Swiss architects Herzog & de Meuron in collaboration with Chinese artist Ai Weiwei, features an intricate web of steel beams that resemble a natural nest. This unique structure is not just an architectural marvel; it also serves as a premier venue for international sporting events, including the Olympics.

Heading west, we encounter another example of metamodernism in architecture — the Elbphilharmonie in Hamburg. This grand building, also designed by Herzog & de Meuron, resembles a ship with a wave-like roof that gracefully rises above the city. Inside, the acoustics and visual effects astound, creating an atmosphere where geometry, art, and innovation seamlessly blend together.

Even residential buildings can embody the trends of metamodernism. Take a look at the skyscraper located at 560 Leonard Street in New York, designed by Herzog & de Meuron. This residential complex stands out with its irregular shapes and smooth transitions between floors, evoking a sense of modern art amidst the rich textures of urban life. Such structures are more than just places to live; they are true works of art that transform the cityscape.

Overall, metamodernism in architecture opens up new horizons, presenting unique and innovative solutions unafraid to experiment with form, space, and materials. This style continues to inspire architects to create magnificent and astonishing structures that turn our cities into galleries of contemporary art.

Conclusion

Metamodernism is a truly unique and captivating artistic movement that skillfully blends contrasting elements to create a new quality of art. At its core is the dialectical interaction of opposites, enabling old and new trends to coexist harmoniously and enrich one another. This movement reaches far beyond painting and architecture, penetrating literature, music, film, and other art forms.

The metamodernist approach reinstates the importance of emotional resonance and authenticity, prioritizing the genuine conveyance of feelings and experiences from the artist to the audience. In cinema, metamodernism can be seen in films like “Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind” (2004) by Michel Gondry, where elements of nonlinear Storytelling and fantastical realism intricately intertwine with profound emotional themes. In literature, the novel “Infinite Jest” by David Foster Wallace embodies this metamodernist trend, as its complex plot and multilayered characters coalesce with humor and tragedy.

The central idea of metamodernism is that the form of art should never overshadow its content, and each work must strive to convey unique emotions that cannot be expressed in any other way. In the realm of music, this is evident in the works of singer Lana Del Rey, where retro aesthetics harmonize with contemporary musical trends, crafting a sound that is both melancholic and emotionally rich. Thus, metamodernism offers not only a novel way to create art but also a new philosophy of perceiving the world, where opposites can collaborate rather than clash to create something astonishingly harmonious and possible.

Metamodernism in Art: Reevaluation and Innovation

Metamodernism is a multifaceted and dynamic movement in art that skillfully intertwines various eras and trends, offering a fresh perspective on long-established concepts. Unlike postmodernism, this approach doesn’t dismiss the past; instead, it reevaluates and adapts it to contemporary realities. Under the banner of metamodernism, intriguing trends have emerged, such as remodernism, reconstructivism, new sincerity, stakism, and the New Weird America.

Drawing inspiration from the revival of early modernism and constructivism, metamodernism goes further by synthesizing these movements with modern ideas. It rejects the irony and cynicism characteristic of postmodernism, asserting the values of humanism and sincerity in the creative process. For instance, stakism revitalizes figurative painting as a counterpoint to conceptual art. Artists like Billy Childish and Charles Thomson exemplify this, merging traditional portraiture with contemporary themes.

Another fascinating direction is “New Weird America,” which blends folk renaissance with elements of psychedelic rock, metal, hip-hop, free jazz, and soul. This genre aims to revive folk traditions while adapting them to modern culture. A prime example is the music of Fleet Foxes, which combines folkloric motifs with experimental sounds, creating deep and multifaceted musical compositions.

The list of trends within metamodernism continues to expand, encompassing both established directions and innovative ideas that are just beginning to gain traction. Our contemporary art history is unfolding right before our eyes, engaging audiences and participants in the creation and interpretation of this evolving narrative. While no one can predict which new trends will emerge tomorrow, those interested in art can actively participate in this journey by exploring the work titled “Identity Politics in Metamodern Art.”

Naturally, any innovative movement inevitably faces criticism, and metamodernism is no exception. Yet, despite skepticism and controversy, this art form continues to evolve, attracting an increasing number of devoted admirers who appreciate its complexity and originality.

Metamodernism: Pros and Cons

Metamodernism is emerging as a new cultural era, succeeding postmodernism and capturing the attention of specialists across various fields. Art historians, philosophers, and psychologists are all eager to delve into the intricacies of this concept. Hot debates surround metamodernism, which is not surprising given its ambitious and integrative nature. Yet, it also faces significant criticism, with detractors arguing that the idea has not been thoroughly developed.

Robin van den Akker and Timotheus Vermuelen, the leading proponents of metamodernism, often find themselves at the center of critique. They are accused of oversimplifying postmodernism and lacking originality in their terminology. For instance, in the article “Critique of the Philosophical Foundations of Metamodernism,” there are claims that the authors confused terms and that their interpretations are questionable. It is also noted that using concepts like “metaxis” and “parataxis” in the context of metamodernism proves to be inaccurate, leading to further confusion.

However, there is an alternative perspective. In the article “Images of Modernity in the 21st Century: Metamodernism,” the author examines the concept from various angles, highlighting its potential to synthesize contrasting trends of contemporary life and give them a cohesive meaning. One notable example of metamodernism in art is the work of multimedia artist Björk, who blends elements from different eras and styles to create unique and profound pieces capable of evoking intense emotions.

Some researchers have even suggested using alternative terms like “protomodernism” instead of “metamodernism” to emphasize the transitional nature of this new epoch. However, this idea has not gained wide acceptance and remains on the fringes of academic discussions.

Nonetheless, the topic of metamodernism remains one of the most discussed and intriguing themes in contemporary art. A prime example can be found in modern cinema, where films like “La La Land” and “The Imitation Game” showcase the duality and harmony of opposites that are characteristic of metamodernism. This emerging cultural phenomenon continues to captivate not just scholars and critics, but also the general public, who are eager to grasp the logic of our rapidly changing 21st-century world.

Try BrainApps
for free

59 courses
100+ brain training games
No ads

Get started